Indeed, the light of Proverbs 30:6 dispels our confusion:
Do not add to his words,
lest he rebuke you and you be found a liar.
lest he rebuke you and you be found a liar.
In total, we said we must avoid Bethel because it is spiritually dangerous, and we said there are two reasons for that. The first reason we examined in length last week, that it promotes false doctrine, and we looked at the heretical teachings streaming from the pulpit to computers and MP3 players near you. If you have not read at least that post, please do so now, because we now turn to the second of these reasons.
Second, Bethel Church is spiritually dangerous because it promotes false signs and wonders.
When Bill Johnson endorsed Todd Bentley back in 2011, he might not have known a few things regarding Bentley's methodology. Perhaps he did not know that Bentley's prophesies proved false, that he abused people onstage, or that his claims of healing were fraudulent. Johnson probably could not have predicted that Bentley would instruct Christians to stop sharing the gospel with unbelievers.
Yet, as we saw last week, signs and wonders mark an important part of Johnson's Bethel's ministry, as well, being part of the church's belief that it has to take spiritual dominion over the world in Christ's name. Unfortunately, that means that we see the same kind of false miracles at Bethel that we saw in Lakeland.
For instance, one of the more spectacular claims is that Bethel worshipers literally bask in the glory-cloud of God (and literally means literally). Their claim is that God, being so pleased with their worship, fills the auditorium with His shekhinah glory-cloud. Bethel even published a video where Bill Johnson explains the phenomena of God's glory descending upon their worship events.
If you are not familiar with the past manifestations of God's glory, it's the fire that held back Pharoah's army while God parted the Red Sea. This was the cloud with its thundering on Mt. Sinai that struck fear into the hearts of all of the people. It filled the mountain at our Lord's transfiguration, causing His disciples to fall on their faces as dead men. Such an occurrence would seem to render my previous post invalid! With its cause of holy terror in mind, we have this "manifestation:"
One word comes to mind: disappointing.
You may witness this glorious confetti if you attend Bethel while its music ministry, Jesus Culture, leads worship. By far, most people know Bethel through Jesus Culture. As mentioned previously, the band entertained 65,000 students at the Georgia Dome during Louie Giglio's Passion 2013 conference back in January, alongside of respected teacher John Piper. Bill Johnson is also sending or "releasing" Banning Liebscher and Jesus Culture to Sacramento to plant a church there. As we saw last week, they see themselves as a movement caught up in taking dominion of culture worldwide, and their brand of Christianity is spreading.
Its vision includes letting people know about God and Heaven. For instance, Kim Walker-Smith, head singer of Jesus Culture, shares her visions of Jesus in the video below.
She sees “Jesus” who has stretch Armstrong like super powers and uses them to show her that he... loves her "this much". Then she has another vision where she not only sees Jesus, she also sees the father who reaches into his chest and tears a piece of his heart out Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom style. She also canoodles with her vision of Christ and both the father and son of her visions apparently have the habit of bursting into maniacal laughter.
Is it fair to call this experience false? Indeed, each and every instance in Scripture where a saint encounters God or the glorified Christ causes fear and dread. In Revelation 1, John saw a powerful Christ with terrible eyes, and John fell to his feet like a dead man. On the other hand, Smith describes a cartoon character who borders on a personality disorder. While we are incapable of judging her genuineness and should not try, we can say with confidence that she did not encounter the true Christ or God of the Bible.
As one Calvary Chapel pastor said while facing down a false prophet, "When miracles are emphasized, Jesus is denied." Unfortunately, as we saw, the Bible fades into obscurity as the church promotes false and heretical teachings. As the drift from the gospel and Word of God continues, the teachings coming out of Bethel Church will only become more bizarre and heretical. Here are a few examples:
- Magical Elements: We already looked at the so-called "glory cloud" and its related "gold" dust appearing during worship services. According to Revival Lifestyle, the gold not only comes to a rest on hands and shirts: it also fills cavities in worshiper's teeth. Diamonds appear in the homes of Bethel church members.
- Tattoo Readings: In addition to "normal" prophetic words, those who attended Bethel's "Power and Love Conference" in February received readings based on their tattoos and piercings. Doug Addison can interpret the hidden messages on your body and even train you to do the same. You don't even have to fly to where he is; for the reasonable fee of $150, he can tickle your ears over the phone for thirty minutes.
- Dead Energy: With Bill Johnson's tacit endorsement, BSSM students followed John Crowder's lead (of the "toking the ghost," "Jehovah-juana" paganism) in "sucking up the anointing" of dead people. As Fawcett notes, Johnson will begin his own holy relic museum to restore the lost anointing of "God's generals" to the present church. Just as Roman Catholics believe that the belongings of late saints can earn gain someone divine assistance and even miracles, Bethel seems intent on calling Christians to the mysticism of object worship.
- Healing Tones: Speaking of object worship, Beni Johnson, Bill's wife, published the theory that love and 528 Hz tuning forks provide healing, neither of which are biblical or scientific, but New Age to the core. In the same post, she likens the sexually promiscuous song "Love Shack" by the B52's to God's call for us to love one another, and one commenter claims that God also uses that song to heal. As the prophet Huey Lewis would say, that's the power of love.
- Angel Rousing: You've heard of guardian angels, but if you have not prayed for a revival angel, you're missing out. Beni Johnson also engages in the "prophetic act" of blowing shofars and yelling "WAKEY WAKEY" to arose sleeping angels who can provide the church with more experiences.
Those coming for healing experience the same want. Despite anecdotal evidence to the contrary, Bethel's fire tunnels and healing rooms leave people with their eyeglasses, hernias, and original woes. Jesus Culture events drag the paralyzed from wheelchairs and leave them in pain and distress. When the glory cloud dissipates, so do the altered states, and bewildered believers face cold reality. Just like it was with the Lakeland revival, stories of healing evaporate as soon as the fog machines power down. They are false miracles, signs of deficient Christianity, and no wonder.
Dear reader, please note this. It matters that Bethel preaches a Christ different from Scripture. It matters when tens of thousands of teens download Jesus Culture music and then embrace false doctrine and experiences. It matters when the Johnsons, the worship leaders of Jesus Culture, and the students of BSSM claim supernatural anointing if they are wrong about it. It matters, and we fail in Christian love for one another to not point it out, for it could possibly keep a brother or sister from stumbling.
I appeal to you, brothers, to watch out for those who cause divisions and create obstacles contrary to the doctrine that you have been taught; avoid them. For such persons do not serve our Lord Christ, but their own appetites, and by smooth talk and flattery they deceive the hearts of the naive. (Romans 16:17-18)